If it was your husband Thank You’s

A word from our sponsor:

Printer-friendly version

Author: 

Blog About: 

Now that the final segment of “If It Was Your Husband” has been posted, I’d like to take a few moments to reflect on the saga and say thank you to some of the folks that got involved with the story. This was the first serial I’ve ever posted. The only reason I posted as a serial was because of the length. I generally write at about 20K words or less, this one topped 40K before the epilogue. The epilogue added an additional 1500 words.

First of all, I’d like to thank all the readers who stuck it out to the final posting. Secondly I’d like to thank my volunteer editor who did a great job of catching typos for me. The only compensation she got reading the whole story in advance. In all she went over the story three times. Once as a whole and then again twice for each segment posted. Thanks Gabi for all your work.

Another person I need to thank is Emma Ann Tate who was a sounding board for me as the story unfolded, helping me deal with the comments and then finally looking over the epilogue as a beta reader and making a good suggestion on how to improve what I was trying to say. Thanks Emma for being my friend and confidant for this story.

Lastly, I’ll throw in an apology to those who found the story upsetting. In a PM one reader disclosed that a particular chapter caused her to have trouble sleeping after reading it. Certainly not the kind of response I was hoping for. She said it was a testament to my skill as a writer that she got so wrapped up in the story… I saw it as a failure to properly develop the character that upset her. Up until this story I’ve written what I call fluff pieces. This was the first that touched on disapproval in anyway by any character in the story.

What follows is my ramblings about the story and how I felt about its reception. Unless you have a morbid curiosity about the inner workings of my mind, you might want to quit reading here.

The early chapters generated a great deal of comments. To my surprise, several readers saw things in the story that as the author, I didn’t. One of the things I insist on when I endeavor to write a story is that I have a firm mental grasp of the backstory; not only of the story itself, but of all the main characters in the story. This keeps the story grounded and minimizes the chance of it ending up with conflicting segments. When writing, I then struggle with just how much of that backstory needs to be revealed to the reader. Too much and I feel the story gets weighted down with facts and drags. I feel that if you don’t have a good hook in the first chapter or for sure by the second chapter then it’s likely that folks are going to opt out of reading. Yet, some of the backstory is a must for the reader understand the motivation of the characters.

It became apparent that I misjudged just how much of Alex and Carrie’s relationship needed to be revealed. It seems a prologue should have been in order to settle the question of what kind of relationship they had. If I’m lucky, maybe I’ll remember that for future writing.

The epilogue was an afterthought. An attempt to rectify that error in judgement regarding the backstory. This story being my first novel length story was a new experience for me as was posting as serial. One of the takeaways from this experience it that I don’t handle waiting too well. Limiting myself to posting weekly put a real strain on my patience. Another is that reading comments on the individual segments didn’t always set well with me because I knew where the story was going and I felt that a number of the readers saw and commented on paths in the future that wouldn’t get the story where it needed to go and weren’t there. They also read into the story elements of the backstory that weren’t in my mind as I wrote the story. I feel that if they had been privy to the whole story they would have been less troublesome for me read.

The final takeaway from this experience it that I’ll likely not post as a serial on longer works. Instead, I’ll post with an interactive Table of Contents that will allow readers to read a chapter or two, close the story and then come back later and using that interactive TOC to jump to the place where they left off to continue reading. I did this when I posted “One Dozen Roses.” I don’t know if readers use it or not, but the option was there.

Comments

Serials

Emma Anne Tate's picture

Thanks for the shout-out, Patricia! You have provided me with so many thoughtful and kind comments on my stories, I was delighted to be able to return the favor in some small degree. :)

I thought your engagement with the comments on your story was really amazing. Very thoughtful and open to seeing your story through other people’s eyes, while at the same time standing by your work. I hope I do nearly so well!

Most of the stories I’ve published in serial form aren’t finished when I start to post them, so the comments are very useful. Lots of times, I find readers are picking up things I missed, or hadn’t really thought about, and it allows me to fine-tune the story as I go. The one longer story that was almost finished before I started posting was Always and Forever, and I found myself impatient about waiting a week to post, much as you were this time. Even there, though, I substantially re-wrote the final chapter after thinking about comments I’d gotten. I can see where comments are more difficult for an already-completed story that is being posted in serial form.

With all that said, I thought this story worked well as a serial, and I enjoyed getting my weekly fix!

Hugs,

Emma

Thank you...

RachelMnM's picture

Not only for crafting this story and all your efforts to make it a worthy read, but for engaging with your readers and their concerns. You're caring in both your craft and response to criticism / critics is yet another example of why BC is such an awesome place to hang out as both an author / reader. There were conversations happening and if we're all talking respectfully to one another we can work things out or at least agree to disagree.

I would encourage you to temper your thoughts on "a failure to properly develop the character". Everyone is going to have their own vision of the story or characters we write and what should happen with the story / characters. I'm okay with that - I don't want to pre-chew the story for them - I'm hoping they see the guard rails I've laid out for the story and fill in what's missing with their own imaginations. With billions of ways the ideas we come up with could be written or interpreted - we can't control their reception.

Much good came out of this story - beside it being an enjoyable read. People talked, there were ideas floated, and BC will be a better place for some of that. Please, take the win - you deserve that and don't let any of this prevent you from creating you next chapter based or short or SOLO stories!

XOXOXO

Rachel M. Moore...

The early chapters generated

SaraKel's picture

The early chapters generated a great deal of comments. To my surprise, several readers saw things in the story that as the author, I didn’t.

When I was in high school, I hated it when English teachers asked us to look for meaning in stories. It was like they expected us to read the mind of people with completely different life experiences than my own. When I started writing my own stories, I wondered if I should put in hidden meanings, since the 'great writers' used them in their stories. Then I read this article:

https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/30937/famous-novelists-s...

A bunch of authors responded to the question - 'Do you purposely put symbolism in your stories'. My favorite response was from Isaac Asimov. -- "Consciously? Heavens, no! Unconsciously? How can one avoid it?"

I've never worried about hidden meanings since, but it is fun to see the things in my stories other people find. Hearing outsiders views of our stories is a gift as it allows us to see our own minds in a way we could never do ourselves.