How much is too much?

Printer-friendly version

Author: 

Taxonomy upgrade extras: 

This is about Violence in stories and may be triggering to many.

So, some of the stories I'm reading just take me to a very dark place and make me very bad company. A few times, various people have asked me to write my own story, so I started on it. Below is an excerpt. This is not for the faint of heart. It spans about a 3 month period in my life. Does anyone really want to read 15 or 16 years of this crap? Does it make you feel like someone beat you up?

Mini Auto Bio
By
Gwen Brown
I’ve tried very hard to write this before but it was far too painful. Just so you know, I am going to post this and go to bed, no drama, so please, nobody worries, OK? Zoe Taylor’s, “Boys Don’t Cry” inspired this. It is only a vignette, more I cannot do.

This scene is not for the faint of heart or those who are easily triggered. You are warned.

She’d been sitting quietly with the family around the puffing wood stove. The rest of the rooms in the un-insulated turn of the century house were chilled to the point that water in a glass would sometimes freeze at night, but this room was quite pleasantly warm, and in fact so warm that she’d actually lain on the worn bare unfinished wooden floor in front of the stove to get out of the heat for a while.

The old house on rural farm land in the Willamette Valley, Oregon had no inside plumbing save one cold water faucet that ran into a sink that drained through the wall and out to the grassy area at the side of the crude wood structure. It had been built of un-barked pine poles, and sided with un-barked wood “half rounds” from some mill. The “half rounds” weren’t really half a log but the rounded section on the edge of a log that the saw cut off before they began to cut dimensional lumber. There was an outhouse in the back yard for sanitary needs, and once a week baths were given in a washtub in the primitive kitchen; the water heated on the wood cook stove.

Lying there, she’d looked up at the clouds of cigarette smoke that hung stratified at different levels in the room. It looked so surreal, and in the very early 50s no one had any idea that the smoke could be harmful to anyone.

Cooled somewhat, she got up and sat back down in the chair next to Sis. The conversation drifted from how much the over fired wood stove was shaking, to how much easier it was to use the tractor her brothers had purchased to run the huge buzz saw to cut the fire wood instead the cross cut saw, and then on to how the boys wanted to rig the horse plow to the tractor so they would not have to use the horse to pull it.

Her illiterate ex-Amish step father was telling her big brothers that the horse was the better way to plow; pointedly letting them know it was how men folk did it. To her, he was really stupid because he’d angrily told her that she was a boy and not a girl like mommy and sis. Her stepfather had been raised in an extremely abusive house hold near Lancaster, PA. So he knew all about living simple.

At the time she did not know that in scant weeks he’d beat her half to death again, this time telling her, you will act like a boy or I will kill you. He’d repeat the same speech several times in the coming years every time she let her true nature out too much, it would happen again. Most other nights of the week, he’d look her up as soon as he got home from work and start yelling at her for not getting some chore done the way he wanted it, then she’d hear the slap of his belt as he took it off. She’d stand there quaking; knowing he would beat her mercilessly despite her most impassioned pleas to not hurt her. Then, when he’d finish, rather than let her weep until she could stop, he’d angrily tell her, “God damn you, stop crying or I’ll give you a reason to cry, you little son of a bitch”. So, she’d sniff, and try to stop shuddering, all the while he looked at her. “God damn you little fucking sissy, pull that lip in you little shit”.

Eventually, he’d leave her alone if she was quiet enough and then she could sneak off to her bed to hide. She’d quietly begin to sob again, being oh so careful so that he could not hear. Once she’d gotten too loud and he pulled her out of bed to beat her again. After that, she worked very hard to conceal her emotions; something very hard for a 4 year old.
She was extremely afraid of him because the first time she met him, it was back in San Diego. She’d been playing in her room and suddenly she could hear this new man that she’d never seen before and mommy arguing, “But Cliff, Gwen is just a baby, don’t hurt her.”
“God damn it Lucille, Gwen is a boy and I am gonna fix that long hair right now”!

They fought back and forth for quite a while and then mom starting crying and screaming, really frightening her.

He’d stomped into the room, grabbed her by the arm, and tore off her little dress, leaving only her diaper. His rough handling, loud cursing and threats made little Gwen begin to quake in fear. He got these hand operated clippers, which were dull and began to cut her hair off so that it was very uneven and almost scalp length. The clippers painfully pulled, making her scream in pain. So, he’d alternately hit her with his open hand and then cut some more hair. When it was done, she was nearly bald, and so shaken that mom took her into the bath room to wash off the hair, put a fresh diaper on her and put her to bed with a bottle.

Gwen sat there looking around the room at her three big brothers and Cliff, her stepfather. ‘I’m not like them. They are so mean to me.’

Then she looked at her step sister and mom. ‘No, I want to be like them. I hate the men’.

With that, she got up and went into Gloria Jean’s room. Seeing her skirt on the back of a chair, she put it on. It was so long that she had to pull the waist band up under her arms. Then, she walked back into the front room with the family and sat down by her mom. Now she’d made herself more like the girls, not the men. She hated the men. They were always so mean.

It was really quiet when she sat down by mommy.

“Mom, Gwen has my skirt on”. Gloria shouted in indignation.

“Gwen, go take Gloria’s skirt off right now”. Mom said.

Gwen’s step father just had to get into the act too. “God damn you little shit, what the fuck are you doing? You want to be a girl”? He shouted.

Still not getting it, Gwen said, “Yes, I want to be like mommy and Gloria”.

“OK, God Damn you, I will make you a girl.”

Confused, Gwen looked at him innocently.

Even as young as she was, Gwen knew that he was mad and was going to hurt her really badly this time. He grabbed one of his sweat shirts and put it on her after Gloria had taken her skirt back. Then he began to taunt her; making fun of her, ridiculing her. Gwen began to cry; mom remaining silent. Everyone else in the family was silent too because none of them wanted to be his next target.

“God damn you, you little sissy, shut the fuck up or I’ll give you a reason to cry!”

She eventually stopped crying, and it terrified her to be sniffing deeply once in a while. She was unable to control that.

To this day, it is one of the ways she knows that she is upset. She’s so adept at hiding her feelings, even from herself, that she’d never know it were it not for the uncontrollable sigh that escapes then. It is very hard to dig around in her own head, find the feelings and console herself. No one else is there.

So, this is why it is so hard to write about my past, and why some stories are so upsetting for me. It does not mean that they are not good writers, but some of it I just can not do. Some of you seem very sad a lot of the time. I am so sorry. However, perhaps it would be best for you to try to avoid things that dredge up old feelings. Sometimes you just need to give yourself a break, perhaps.

Comments

First, thank you for sharing

I am at a loss for advice to give about writing. But am honored by trust shown by sharing and felt compelled at least respond to such honesty.

In other times and places I would offer hugs and comfort, but don't know the way things are done here. (I'm new).

I too abandon stories that are triggering. Past experience has shown that doing otherwise usually has bad outcomes.

It is not a story. It is the truth.

No, I am not going to publish this as a story. I don't want it around to trigger too many people.

It was my hope that people would realise that writing really graphic and painful things can take the author and those who read to very bad places. I only used it to illustrate my point. It is completely true though.

Now, I am gonna let it die a natural death.

My stories are gonna take a big change in direction, and I am gonna try to write light, humourous stories; ones that will hopefully leave a smile on the face of the reader.

Much peace

Khadijah Gwen

I have a cold chill down my back...

Andrea Lena's picture

...and I am weeping. Please consider posting this as a standalone autobiographical story. It is too powerful and important to be neglected as a blog that disappears all too soon. I am copying this for my library. You are such a brave soul to write this; it is one of the most powerful narratives I have ever read. I cannot begin to thank you enough for this.


Dio vi benedica tutti
Con grande amore e di affetto
Andrea Lena

  

To be alive is to be vulnerable. Madeleine L'Engle
Love, Andrea Lena

How much is too much?

Gwen, there are some things best left in the poast if in dealing with them causes you only pain with no b beneficial effects.

    Stanman
May Your Light Forever Shine
    Stanman
May Your Light Forever Shine

The past is never past,

if you never deal with it. That's where we get ulcers, colitis, neurological and psychological disorders of all sorts, and even cancer, if you believe some of the medical journals, etc. Everyone feels the pain of the past if they've been hurt. It's how they feel it and how well they learn to cope with it that remains the difference.

Writing may be a great form of catharisis. What Gwen perhaps is suggesting with good evidence is that it's not always beneficial to POST a story such as this. I personally derived a great deal of comfort from this; knowing that I wasn't alone in my own victimization, and I am very grateful to Gwen for this.

Yes, the past is the past.

And I lived it for quite a while, but one day I just had to begin to distance myself from it, and think about other things. It is the only healthy thing to do, and we don't have many friends if all we talk about is downer subjects. At some point we just need to move on, and I have begun to limit my exposure to those who don't.

I have some people in my life who want to share their T experience with me, but from personal experience, I know that it is not all pink and vanilla pudding. There are times when things are very hard, and there is no way that I want to give anyone the idea that I encouraged them to do it. I heard a person once tell me, "well you told me to transition", and they were now quite sad. I will not allow that to happen to me ever again.

Gwen

Fiction. It's incredible

Fiction writing is simply wonderful; it can take you to the most delightful places in the world, and yes, it can take you to hell.

Sometimes, it is necessary to write to heal the hurt inside, but it sounds as though you are past that. And once anyone has written one story for that reason, it's either worked or it has not. I believe that if it didn't work first time, it certainly isn't going to work the next, and all it's going to do is to indefinitely prolong the agony, continually opening the sore inside.

The whole world is at your fingertips. So, rather than recreating hell, why not create something beautiful? And this applies not just to you, Gwen, but to every author on this site.

Opening the door to a peaceful place?

Yes, I agree with you Lindale. I've been impatient with others and myself. I hope that I can finish Katia on a happy note, and then move on to much more positive subject matter.

Much peace

Khadijah

We've chatted


at great length about this stuff Khadija and discussed the mechanisms we use to circumvent the recollection to block the hurt, not the memory but the hurt - the consequences of the memories.
Just like you Khadija, I find myself emotionally exhausted by years of dwelling upon the rejection, the brutality and injustice ... so much so that I rarely touch upon abuse anymore in my stories.

One bizarre outcome of coming to BC is that I seem to perceive that some transexuals achieve a sort of social peace once they have transitioned. That is to say, not a sexual peace or an emotional peace but their social function adjusts to accommodate their having been 'cured' and they find a social peace. This often leads them to steup aside from the TG scene forever; for having become women as far as it matters at fifty or sixty years of age, that they no longer have an interest in transgenderism.

I look at these individualsd and wonder if transitioning could be used as a device to find social peace and enable an individual to leave the transgendered scene forever.
My problem is that while living as a woman, I would probably still find transvestism an exciting and stimulating activity that keeps me firmly in the TG scene, and that includes clubbing and behaving (by some people's mores') outrageously.

Your's faithfully,

Listen to me being all formal and correct!

Skype you tommorrow kid, it's just so much easier to talk and share feelings.

Love and hugs.

Beverly.

One very confused T/G

Growing old disgracefully.

bev_1.jpg

My most gracious thanks, milady. :)

Yes, I agree, and for weeks I've felt something churning in my innards wanting to claw its way out, and I think that you are right. I am afraid that I have not been very good company to some of my friends recently and inshallah, I will work all that out eventually. Hopefully there is a place that we come where we can be supportive of the pain of others without being enabling in an unhealthy way.

Much peace

Khadijah