Road to Myself 28: Mythbusters

Printer-friendly version

Author: 

Taxonomy upgrade extras: 

Road to Myself - 28: Mythbusters
Annette MacGregor

I generally enjoy the Mythbuster's TV show... And, I don't know about any of you, but I know I've wondered about some of the things I've read in stories about transitions, hormones and the like. Some of them are repeated over and over in story after story. Other things, I see only now and again.

The other day, I had an experience that reminded me of one of those "staples" of many M2F stories, and it got me thinking... So, I decided to expound upon a number of these myths, and while I won't go to their level of rigor in testing the myths, I will speak to them from my own personal experience.

This is NOT my typical "road" blog... This is more of a retrospective where I compare some of the fiction staples to my actual experiences... And, before anyone gets upset, more often than not, there HAS been a basis in fact of many of them, even if I didn't recognize it at first... So, I'll "sorta" use the Mythbuster's grading scale and well, we may as well dive in.

1) Showers - they can really stimulate growing (or grown) boobs.
At first, I was going. No way... I took showers and nothing... Turns out, it was my old fashioned shower head. My first shower with one of those new "high power" heads. Let me tell you, I jumped. No - it wasn't sexually stimulating, but oh, yeah, the girls told me about it. And, the clincher - back before HRT, I never noticed much difference in shower head affects. So, only partially busted, at least for me. Yes, it can be stimulating, but not in any sexual way. It's possible it affects someone else that way, but there certainly IS more sensitivity.

2) Towels - must pat dry, as they are painful
This is another one I figured HAD to be an "urban legend". The way the stories went - a new girl was warned to always pat themselves dry. There was no need to pat myself dry. But, this is the one that got me thinking last week - I was in a different hotel than I normally stay in. And, rather than soft - the hotel's towels were prickly and stiff (no fabric softener in the dryer???)... Now, it felt good on my dry back (lotion would have been better, but I couldn't reach there and didn't have anyone handy to do the job)... But, when I got near the girls; nope, I was NOT going to rub them with THAT towel... Pat dry it was - for the week - but not over the entire body - just the sensitive areas. I talked to my wife about it, and she said "Yeah, that's why I buy expensive towels. They absorb more water, and they don't hurt when you dry off." So, this one is mostly confirmed.

3) Skin softens
In a lot of fiction I read it seemed the protagonist's skin got softer really fast. Thinking back to my years of HRT, I can say the "fast" bit was wrong for me, but after a few years there's no question my skin IS softer - some areas (inside elbow, for example) almost as soft as the proverbial baby's behind. So, in the words of Mythbusters - "confirmed".

4) Development speed - You have significant growth in 6 months.
Seems like so many stories have people having significant growth really fast - in some, it's a matter of weeks. What did I have after a month? Good question... I actually made notes when I noticed things changing. At the one month point, I was no longer able to say "I THINK" when saying there was something going on. There was definitely a bud - very small. By six months? significant is NOT the term I would use... More like sunny side up eggs (a term used in one story I read). And, my growth has continued. By a year the girls were definitely small "A" cup... and seemed to have leveled off. Something I did notice is that the girls did not grow smoothly. They grew in spurts (the most significant changes seemed to occur when my HRT dose was adjusted (usually down - yes, reduction in my estroidal seemed to result in an increase in cup size... Go figure). Now - four years later, I'm a "C", but my doc is convinced they're still gradually growing. (They can stop now, if they like... I do NOT need DD+!!!) So, I'd say that while this one is BUSTED, it's true with a longer time frame.

5) After you develop, you can't hide it.
If you consider a "C" cup developed, then I can simply say this one is "Busted"... None of those I've worked with - who now know - had a clue. Most of the others who kno me also appear to have no clue. The exception, if you don't take a small effort to hide them, yeah, some will notice (Note to self - a tight polo shirt - with none of the buttons buttoned - and a contrasting bra... Makes it difficult to miss... Not impossible, just difficult.) So, I'd say this one is BUSTED, unless you don't watch your subconscious that is trying to "out" you...

6) High heels are really hard to walk in And you need to work up.
This, like the next one depends. I never had ANY trouble with heels in the 2 to 2 1/2 inch range from the first day I wore them. On the other hand, I know several girls that can't manage in less than an inch (TGirl or other). So, this one is in the middle.

7) High heels are trivial to walk in
For me, as I said, no problem up to about 3 inches. It took me a few minutes to figure out how to adjust my stride when I tried on some luscious blue satin pumps with 5 inch heels. (My older daughter was going "No way you're already walking in those!") But, after a bit, I could still walk - but I was beginning to feel it in my lower legs. I suspect I'd have issues after a few hours. And, my wife would never consider heels that high... Her response "I'd break my ankles." So, this one I'd say is sorta busted.

8) Women's clothing fits so easily
This is another one that has a mixed answer. I've found that some things do fit easily (shoes) but others, I have to be careful. My arms are a wee bit longer than is normal in females that developed all their life that way. Not a lot, but some. Another difference is the broader shoulders... And male pattern belly... Add them together and blouses become a challenge - not impossible, but a challenge. Slacks - tight ones... Don't work for me, as the growth gets in the way... But most others work fairly well and fit better than the men's pants I've worn over the years unless they have a high waist. (That male belly causes trouble there, but "below the waistline" hits mine quite nicely. So, I'd say busted, but fixable.

9) Hair style - it's easy to have one that simply switches back and forth between guy and girl
This is a fiction. You can have a more "neutral" style that you can dress up or hide, but not anything extremely masculine or feminine and hope to switch between the two. Best I've been able to come up with is long hair (shoulder blade length) held in a pony tail (scrunchies are best to avoid breaking hair - for me - but they do look more feminine). I can wear it down or in a high tail and look more feminine or pulled back in a low tail and all I get is "Sir"... Busted, but only if you're looking for an extreme style.

10) You can't sleep on your stomach after you develop
This is totally busted. My sinuses won't let me spend much time on my back, so I switch between sides and occasionally my stomach. That said, I've found sleeping at a 45 degree angle with a pillow to prop - or spooned - is the easiest thing. This was even while the girls were actively growing. I've heard tails otherwise, maybe those girls have more growth than I do. (My older daughter can't, but she has a "G" cup.)

11) Developing a feminine voice is automatic/easy
Umm. Not for me. I used to be able to manage a really good Darth Vader imitation "Luke, I am your mother"... But, that doesn't really fit with my goals. That said - I can't do it any more (well, not any good). My voice appears to have actually climbed a "little" Probably just settling in to a little higher pitch in my natural range. I've never managed to get ma'am'd on the phone *sighs* But, have done okay when out- en-fem... But, it's not been easy and I know I have a LONG way to go (and not much time left). so, this one I think can be called BUSTED. Oh, there are probably a few of us out there who have naturally higher pitch voices and can do it fairly easily - perhaps they have better ears than I...I dunno. (I do know that some of us do develop REALLY NICE voices!

12) Long fingernails are easy to get used to.
Totally busted... You have to learn how to get dressed again; Learn to type; To pick things up... The works. If you don't learn gradually as the finger nails grow, you have problems! I can watch my wife & daughters go through this! The time I tried with false nails (for a few hours)... It struck home.

13) You get massive mood swings on hrt
This didn't happen to me. My family and I did notice - after I'd been on injected HRT for about six months, I got a bit moody in the days before my shots. I also had minor mood swings, but nothing crazy (like what my teen daughter went through). And, the swings were associated with hormone level in the blood - not just being on HRT. Also - as time has gone one - and my body become accustomed to the right hormones running around, even these have eased... (Sorta like what we see as our daughters grow up and come to terms with their hormones. Amazing, huh.) I was on oral HRT for a while before switching over, and there were no noticeable mood swings there - the hormone level was kept at a steady level. So, I'd say the "massive" part is busted, but if you drop massive - it's confirmed conditionally, depending on the form of HRT you're using.

14) You find it easier (almost compulsory) to cry at things that never used to affect you
This took a while for me... But it DID (and has) happened. I have to be vigilent in guy mode to make sure it doesn't happen there, but I cry in movies. I cry when happy,etc. So, confirmed - but it takes a while it's NOT right away.

15) You automatically gain a good fashion sense
Busted... I don't know how many tgirls I've seen who seem to not be able to put an attractive outfit together. Color sense is part of it, but also recognizing what styles fit your body type. I do fine on color sense, and can recognize when something works for me once I put it on... But, on the rack? I don't know until I try it. That said, I did better color matching years ago than many, and was dragged on many a shopping trip, to say yes / no... LOL (Funny, not had so many trips recently - certainly not for me.) So, yes, busted. If you don't have one before, transition doesn't magically give you one. (That said, it IS something that can be learned!)

16) Other women automatically accept you and include you in conversation like any other
This one is mixed. Mostly, I'd say not really, but every now and again, the conversation can go indirections where a guy would not go - and a girl wouldn't go with a guy. I recall chatting with one of my daughter’s friends, my daughter and her boy friend and some how cup size came up... Turns out the girl and I both wear 38C so, at her instigation "high Five"... And off we were talking about bras and such... My daughter joined in... And a minute later, her boyfriend was embarrassed and walked off... The three of us laughed. That was a case where I felt "included" but other times, I know it's not happened. So, I think it's more we can be "accidentally" included and participate and are accepted then. But, it doesn't occur to most other women to discuss those things with us... Perhaps they assume we're not interested. I dunno... So, I'd say conditionally busted.

17) You automatically desire and know how to "shop"
This, like the color sense, is one of those things that if you don't have before, you don't have after. And, since you're not necessarily "included" when the girls go shopping, you may not have an opportunity to learn.

18) If not already, Chocolate becomes critical
I used to enjoy Chocolate, but I could do without and it didn't bug me... Since HRT started - at least a year into it... There've been times I've CRAVED chocolate! (Yes, I'd even grab a hand full of chocolate chips to feed the beast.) So, from personal experience, I'd say "confirmed".

19) Transition and you become beautiful
I can't speak from personal experience, but I don't see how. Perhaps, if you're young enough when you transition and have the natural genetics to support it (Like the Canadian T-Girl competing to be Miss Canada for the Miss Universe competition she's a lovely 23 yr old!). I don't believe anyone would try to claim I'll be beautiful following transition. The best I can hope for is to pass, and in the right lighting conditions maybe a bit more. (How many 50 yr old ladies are "beautiful" if they weren't beautiful before?) So, for most of us, I think the "beautiful" thing is busted, but it is possible to become not just passable, but even a bit attractive (with a surgeon's help). So, if you drop beautiful and just say become a woman, yes, that's very possible.

20) Transition and the world becomes better (all problems solved).
Somehow I don't think so. I've yet to find anyone who never had any problem after transition. Some times the problems change? (Okay, many times). This is another I don't YET have personal experience with. But, I can't see any existing problems (except with our vision of self) going away with transition.

I'm sure many/most of you that read this have other bits they've read that are more or less true based on personal experience. Feel free to share.

As always, comments, questions, etc. are welcome.

Thanks for reading.
Annette

Comments

my experiances so far

1. I usually prefer a bath to a shower when its a choice, so i havent noticed this yet.

2. Depends on how rough the towel is.

3. Havent really noticed this happening to me. Mind you, I dont spend a lot of time checking, either.

4. Dont know if it counts as "significant" because I'm probably just an A cup or less, but I did see a difference after 6 months

5. Why would you want to hide your boobs?

6./7. I find heels not easy - not because I lose my balance, but just find my leg muscles get tired quicker. Mind you, I dont wear them very often, so its not like I've had much chance to get used to them.

8. I have found that some woman's clothes are a bit short in the arms or torso, or both for me. Plus, I have a serious belly, so sometimes it feel like I should be in maternity clothes ...

9. I have a bit of a bald spot, so feminine hairstyles are really hard to make for me. But I'm loving having slightly longer hair...

10. I sleep on my stomach, but I'm not done developing yet - I hope.

11. I struggle with my voice. I can make it softer, but not much higher, at least not for long. But sometimes it drops down when I'm not focused on it, so that sucks.

12. my fingernails are way too short for me to test this.

13. I've had mood swings, but I'm also a bit manic-depressive...

14. Sometimes, I cry for no good reason. Other times, I really, really want to, and cant.

15. No way. I suck at fashion.

16. I now have some female friends at work, but we havent reached the BFF stage or anything. I still feel the lack of a lifetime of girl socialization is keeping me on the outside looking in.

17. I may desire to shop, but I dont know how good I am at it.

18. Chocolate is good. Peanut butter is better.

19. I have a friend who says I'm beautiful. But they said that before I started transitioning, so I think that doesnt count. I'll settle for not being mistaken for a dude.

20. I havent transitioned fully yet, and may never be able to. But I'm not dumb enough to think it would be a magic wand that would make everything perfect. Life is always a challenge, male, female, or in between.

Well, those are my answers.

DogSig.png

well...

I'm still not officially transitioning, so at least some of this I can't say anything about, but...

1) As you've found, it depends on the shower head. My mom's place has a fully adjustable one with full spray, edge-only spray, dribble, massage, jet, and "normal" modes... Back before she lost water pressure up there for some reason, the full spray and massage modes were a little tingly, the jet mode though... OMG! After she lost water pressure, none of the other modes even tickled, and only jet could get any reaction, and it wasn't nearly even what full spray or massage modes did when there was water pressure. Unfortunately, my apartment I've moved into is equipped with just a primitive "normal" shower head. Yes, I've had slight mammary development for years, though it was never more than slight budding until recently, and trust me, the slight budding sensitivity has nothing on them now since I've begun to herbally decrease my testosterone poisoning.

2) I have a favorite towel... It's super awesome soft and absorbent... I never use any other towels.

3) I think my skin is softening somewhat, but, like you've said, it's definitely very slow and gradual. My skin has thinned rather drastically on the other hand...

4) I have a feeling this is very much dependent on individual genetics. I've had rather surprising development for using an herbal concoction, such that everyone seems to claim shouldn't happen. Makes me wonder how I'll respond whenever I can get on a properly regimented real deal...

5) As you hinted at, I think this has more to do with your behavior than your physical appearance. People are used to seeing what they want to see, and guys are even less likely to notice anything if you don't smack em over the head with it. Women don't tend to notice physical changes UNLESS you're doing something that calls attention to it, meaning, behaviorally. I highly doubt I've really changed enough physically to be taken as female on that alone, but I'm often taken for being female (or at least a little bit of an odd male) when I'm not paying attention to what I'm doing... And I think it's, as you said, subconsciously outting myself.

6 & 7) The most I've done seriously are 2 inches, that's the most I was willing to risk getting at the time, and they're platform type not really "heels" per say. Honestly, don't have much problem moving in them at all, though they're definitely NOT intended for doing any manual labor in. Speaking of... My work boots are femme now and have about an inch of raised heel... I've already remarked on this - it was really inconvenient to work in at first, but my feet gradually grew more adapted to spending all day like that, and now I actually have a harder time working on flats... It's getting warmer now and so I'm wearing athletic shoes to work on some days, and my feet are almost crying for me to put em back in the heels... So I really think this is just a matter of what you're used to wearing.

8) Agreed on the mixed bag here... I find it's mostly a style thing for me though... Some clothes are just not designed for long skinny limbs, while some are. I just have to find the ones that are designed for long skinny limbs. My shoulders are also a LITTLE bit too broad, but not nearly as much so as many t-girls report, and I've actually known a number of natal women with broader. I am very quickly losing my "male" belly, in fact, it's almost completely deflated now, it's all migrating to my breasts, hips, and butt. This, I suspect, is actually age of transition. I'm 26, and my male fat was stored almost evenly across my body, so I never really had a terribly pronounced male belly to begin with.

9) Wouldn't know anything about this - first, I'm still only at about 3 inches or so - this barely makes it to the nape of my neck immediately after a shower and soaking wet. Second, I have CRAZY hair, thick, heavy curls about every quarter inch, and frizzles to make Miss Frizzle look flat. Seriously, I can muss my hair just so to make my curls stand up straight and proud, and they'll stubbornly stay that way even with the wind blowing on it hard, unless I very carefully comb it back and tuck everything together to hold it down under it's own weight... Basically, until I do SOMETHING to tame my hair, it can't BE styled.

10) I'm pretty modest on my development, so I'll not attempt to speak to "after", however, I've NEVER been comfortable sleeping either on my back, or my stomach. I've always balled up on my side clutching my pillows.

11) Seems I'm one of the lucky ones here... I'm finding that convincing people on the phone that I really AM the guy they're looking for is becoming very difficult.

12) DEFINITELY AGREE! Heck, mine grow in so fast that it's the same as not having time to grow into them. It's a huge change from before when my nails never grew right...

13) I've had a few massive mood swings, but I'm not sure I'd attribute it to my herbals so much as just natural stresses in my life.

14) Well... I've always been quick to cry, I've always had to force it down in male mode, which was always extremely uncomfortable, so when I'd watch things with others I'd always run out during such scenes that I knew were likely to cause me that difficulty...

15) I really don't have enough experience about this yet.

16) Interestingly, women were doing this with me a lot even before I knew myself what I was... I just naturally gravitated towards hanging out with them more, and they forgot I was even there...

17) Dunno about knowing how... I don't have enough money to just go crazy, so I'm still stuck in my old frugal ways... The desire to be able to just go shop till I drop is definitely there though, and never used to be.

18) Chocolate AND peanut butter! Mmmm.... Reese's... Nutty Bars... Mmmmmmmmmmmmmmm...

19) I wish... But then, as I've noted on my blog, some boys are already starting to make offhand comments before realizing I'm a "guy"... maybe I've got more going for me on this than I am willing to admit to myself. I just can't imagine anyone thinking me pretty...

20) Again, I wish. The real reality for me is that to even contemplate transition means my world comes to an end... yet I have to do it anyways. My world is my family. Parents. Siblings. Cousins. Nieces and nephews... If they can't transition with me, it'll near ruin me, and that's the rotten truth. The other rotten truth though is that to NOT transition will ruin me just as surely, perhaps even more. I think I maybe can survive losing a good third or so of my family... But if I turn back, try to close the box I've just opened, I'll surely do something stupid to myself eventually. Heck, just simply NOT living would do it probably. I'm not sure I could go back to the slow spiritual suicide I'd undertaken before, I'd probably end up deciding to end it. The only reason it was tolerable before was because I'd locked myself away.

Abigail Drew.

Um...

Angharad's picture

Breast growth doesn't settle down until after surgery and can take months. Before surgery it takes years to happen, as per biological females.

I would suggest that transition is the beginning of a whole new basket of troubles but by then you're more or less committed to facing them.

Fashion sense? I know when I see something that will suit me - most of the time, and I'm good with colour matching. For those who aren't, dark colours are slimming and black goes with most things, I've even seen it with brown - heresy when I was growing up. I dond't think it's innate, rather learned from being with other women.

Shoes, heel height tolerance is very individual and involves flexibility, sense of balance, foot health and so on. I rarely wear anything beyond 3" and even then my left ankle tends to turn over after multiple sprains. Remember too, that most transwomen are tall, so wearing heels draws attention.

Male bodies have longer limbs and broader shoulders and chests. It's generally a fact. The only useful thing is that female bodies are so variable.

Hormones can affect mood, temperature control, muscle mass, fat distribution, skin dryness, nail growth, and so on. They can also increase risk of thrombosis and various cancers while reducing the risk of prostate cancer. Smoking and taking oestrogen is an extra risk factor.

Voice can be modulated with practice until it becomes second nature, but also the way you speak is important as is your vocabulary - but not every woman finds everything 'adorable'. Most women swear less than men. Always let people accept you as female before you speak, if it's possible and practice speaking on a phone - it highlights pitch and accent.

After surgery you will be more prone to UTIs (water infections) so personal hygiene is essential.

I'll stop now, Myth or should that be Mythith, it's getting boring.

Angharad

Mostly agree

Nearly three years since I went "full time," I'd say my experiences have been mostly similar, but:

8) Women's clothing fits so easily--being tall and skinny, i.e. built like a supermodel but without the big fake boobs, I actually found that women's cuts of clothing in appropriate sizes usually fit me better than men's had, especially once I started to develop a bit of a figure. Why women are supposed to aspire to look like a skinny boy I have no idea, but hey, it works for me.

11) Developing a feminine voice is automatic/easy--Automatic? Easy? Not for me, no. It is achievable though, with training and practice. After nine months or so of seeing a voice coach a couple of years ago, I am now consistently "ma'amed" on the phone. And I used to sound like Clint Eastwood. I have a couple of friends who self-taught (though having a coach helps a lot) and some (mostly younger) who learned in far less time than I. The biggest prieces of the puzzle are -1- RECORD YOURSELF and play it back over and over, listening and playing and experimenting with your voice and adjusting until you sound how you want to sound; -2- practice a LOT but not until your voice gets tired/sore; and -3- keep at it, put in the effort until you get it. And remember that pitch isn't nearly as important as timbre (resonance), intonation, and choice of words or turns of phrase in "gendering" a voice. Even in the same region and subculture, women and men really do almost speak different dialects with different accents.

16) Other women automatically accept you and include you in conversation like any other--your experience mostly matches mine, but I've found as time goes on, it does seem to be gradually happening more often. I think maybe it has to do with my feeling more and more natural and confident of myself as time goes on; the more comfortable I am with myself, it seems, the more comfortable others are with me.

19) Transition and you become beautiful--"become," maybe not. But I know a couple of pretty "boys" who transitioned into (physically) beautiful girls, and I've met a couple of t-girls who with some cosmetic surgery became absolute stunners. I also know a few who looked very masculine and un-pretty as men who are quite attractive after spending $30-40,000 on FFS. It depends on what you start with and how much you're willing to spend to enhance it surgically.

20) Transition and the world becomes better (all problems solved)--no, this does not happen, BUT. I have gone through a couple of THE worst episodes of my life since I transitioned (not directly related to transitioning), and I was MUCH better able to bear them than I would have been pre-transition because I don't have to spend so much of my mental energy maintaining my "disguise," my fictional male persona. The problems didn't go away, no, but they've become MUCH easier to bear and to deal with.

personal what is's

kristina l s's picture

Showers.... Stimulate I don't think, but feel if the pressure is high, yes

Towels.... Hmm can't imagine ever using a really rough towel by choice and I've never felt the need to pat, except perhaps after sunburn.

Skin softening.... yep, but takes a while.

Development.... Well after two weeks I had very tender nipples, but it took a couple of years to get more than little buds. After more than a few I still only manage a modest B.

Hiding... Pretty easy as people see what they expect for the most part and being tall and lanky makes it easier again. Short of accentuating them in some way I could have perhaps worn a singlet and they might think I had small man boobs unless something else tipped the scale.

Heels.... Never had a problem though I'll admit minor stumbles at first. Really high is tricky regardless of who you are and like I said I'm tall ( 6' ) so I don't do really tall. I prefer not to walk into door frames. But some heels sure, I stand out already so...

Clothing.... Ah, broad shoulders, long torso and arms so it's often tricky and you have to pick and choose. Mostly separates as dresses are usually not cut quite right but there's always exceptions.

Hair.... I've had long hair pretty much since High School with a couple of slips along the way and a pony tail or not can tip things one way or the other especially with other 'clues'

Sleeping.... I do the pillow thing as a physical and I guess emotional comfort but I can and do sometimes sleep on my stomach. Perhaps easier as I am not huge so that might vary.

Voice... work at it. It will slide upwards slightly over time but the vocab and patterns need work to make it naturally femme for most including me.

Nails.... very long will make things awkward for a while. Modest length is no biggee though.

Mood swings.... Yep, for me I seem to go into a bi monthly/ quarterly depressive cycle but I've never plotted it as such and the intensity will vary depending on assorted real world factors.

Crying.... definitely becomes easier/ more natural after a while.

Fashion sense.... Umm, for most this one requires work. Just cause you'd love to wear whatever don't make it a good idea.

Acceptance.... very variable, but if you are in a group it does come part of the flow until there's an 'awkward' moment. Time and ease plays with this one.

Shopping... Ummm, it becomes more desirable as the variety expands but not necessarily simpler. One a those fun paradox thingies. Cough.

Chocolate... Hmmm, maybe more desirable but I always loved chocolate without ever needing it, so...

Transition bringing beauty... Errr, nope. You may be happier and more at ease with yourself but the rest all depends on the original material. I aint no beauty as those that have seen me will attest. Not ugly and I mostly pass just fine but pretty, cough cough...

Transitioning - All better.... Well that all depends, Yes you might be more yourself and hence more right but problems are still problems and new ones wander along and..... no magic bullet. Surgery is just another part of that too, one I have yet to manage. Attitood... be 'appy as they say.

Kristina

TG tropes: experiences and comments

Aljan Darkmoon's picture

Shower heads: I have heard that shower massage heads on flexible hoses are very popular among women for stimulating another part of the female anatomy… I vaguely recall seeing some very frank discussion on a web forum comparing the effectiveness of different makes and models.

Heels: As has been pointed out, difficulty depends on the person. It may also depend upon when the person starts wearing them. I cannot remember the first time I tried on my mom’s heels, but I do recall that I was walking in her 1960’s 4-inch stilettos (much to the consternation of my family)–including in a pair of single-soled stiletto mules that afforded no ankle support whatsoever–at a very young age, with no difficulty. I first tried 5-inch heels in the 1980’s, and recall that it took me a few weeks before I could walk gracefully in them. Now days, heels less than 3 inches feel like flats to me. :}

At my peak I stood only 5-foot 5 (5-3, now), so the added height is much appreciated. When I outgrew my mom’s shoes (also at a young age), I started shopping (on the quiet) for my own. Fortunately, my feet stopped growing at US women’s size 9, so that I can enjoy the fashions available to most women.

Heels are my addiction and my passion, and I’ve even dreamed of designing them. I have learned that not all shoes are created equal, and that some heels provide much better arch and ankle support than others. Design, construction, and fit make all the difference in ease of wearability, regardless of heel height.

Voice: I do not recall reading any stories that described voice development as easy, though I have read many that ignore the issue entirely. Of course, in stories where the transformation is through magic, mutation, alien technology, lightning strikes, etc., all bets are off, as an automatically feminized voice is often part of that trope.

Nails: I had to get used to mine, too, even though I try to keep them around a quarter of an inch or shorter. I think even more stories ignore this issue entirely than the “learning to walk in heels” issue. It’s like so many mainstream authors who gloss over or ignore entirely the foreign language issue when moving their characters to another place or time. This is not so much a trope as it is a failure to write a plausibly realistic story.

Fashion sense: I don’t recall seeing too many stories (if any at all) that ignore this learning experience, since the obligatory “mall trawl” is only the second most common TG trope, next to the androgynous “pretty boy” who becomes stunningly beautiful when properly dressed. Most TG stories seem to detail a cisgendered protagonist’s adaptation to an unwanted transition or feminization, with extra focus on matters of fashion and deportment. Stories that gloss over or ignore what the protagonist must learn tend to get lots of pointed comments about plausibility and suspension of disbelief.

Beauty after transition: Usually in stories about magical (and magic-like) transformations, otherwise the protagonist is potentially beautiful (and isolated for lack of masculinity) before transition or feminization, and needs only a makeover and training to bring that beauty forth. Again, this latter trope seems to be the most popular in TG fiction.

Transition into a sylvan paradise: While some authors may be guilty of “the grass is greener on the other side” to some degree, I think this is an oversimplified criticism of most stories. Instead, I notice that most stories have one or both of two common themes:

  1. Protagonists discover that the role expectations of their target genders are much more congruent with their personalities and temperaments than the genders they are leaving behind, with the result that their lives become more about fulfillment and less about sheer survival.
  2. Protagonists of involuntary transitions discover the benefits and advantages of their new genders, and come to enjoy them more than the ones they have left behind.

The very best TG story I have read that explores these themes is Live Long and Prosper by Brandy Dewinter.

TGtropes: I have often thought of starting a wiki, modeled after the increasingly popular tvtropes.org. As usual with my ideas, other people have already thought of them. While some TG tropes have been described on tvtropes.org, a few artists (mostly on DeviantArt) have been creating a genre of web comics that they call “TGtropes,” to ridicule and satirize the tired clichés of TG fiction. Fortunately, more TG fiction authors are learning what successful mainstream authors have always known: if the real life aspects of your story are about things not familiar to you, then you better go research them, because they will be familiar to many of your readers.