IARG cover issue

I'm trying to decide if I really want to use the current cover I have for "Rosemary".

Pros: It is professionally done, it looks nice...the characterizations are just. About. There.
Cons: The model for Kristi is Differnet from the character description in the text and the cover makes it look like a romance novel...which it isn't.

Would it be better to use the following picture (or one like it, of the same model) than the current version?

Current cover

"Person who Kristi is sort of based on but not exactly but she is ALMOST like the character..."

I woulld like to think option 2 is a bit more realistic, less "romance novel-ish".
But, I'm still new at this...

Click Like, Love or Thank to appropriately show your appreciation for this post: