IARG cover issue

I'm trying to decide if I really want to use the current cover I have for "Rosemary".

Pros: It is professionally done, it looks nice...the characterizations are just. About. There.
Cons: The model for Kristi is Differnet from the character description in the text and the cover makes it look like a romance novel...which it isn't.

Would it be better to use the following picture (or one like it, of the same model) than the current version?

Current cover
0B60B89F-9A14-4B30-A315-F0911F015718-229-0000002B22FE27A5.jpeg

"Person who Kristi is sort of based on but not exactly but she is ALMOST like the character..."
IMG_0079_0.JPG

I woulld like to think option 2 is a bit more realistic, less "romance novel-ish".
But, I'm still new at this...

Click Like, Love or Thank to appropriately show your appreciation for this post: